Best Stove Top Griddle for Pancakes: Complete Reviews with Comparison

Spread the love

Pancakes are a favorite American breakfast food with a rich history dating back more than 5,000 years. Granted the ingredients in these delicacies has and continues to change over the years, which only serves to increase their popularity. Aside from their limitless flavors and delicious pairing capability with maple syrup, pancakes make for a quick filling and sumptuous breakfast food.

They offer you an easy way to start off your family’s day on a full stomach without breaking a sweat. Modern technology has gone a long way in giving you a leg up when you need to make pancakes. There are a host of specially crafted griddles on the market to ensure that all cooking sessions deliver delicious and appetizing pancakes.

This detailed guide reviews some of the best stove top griddles available on the market to help you get one that suits your specific culinary needs.

Comparison Chart

Lodge LPGI3 Pro-Grid Cast Iron Reversible 20″ x 10″ Griddle Pan

Calphalon Contemporary Hard-Anodized Aluminum Nonstick Cookware

All-Clad 3020 Hard Anodized Aluminum Griddle

Hawkins Futura Q28 Non-stick Flat Dosa Tava Griddle

Cuisinart MCP45-25NS Double Burner Griddle

Best Stove Top Griddle for Pancakes Reviews

1. ​Lodge LPGI3 Pro-Grid Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle

The pro-grid iron griddle makes a cakewalk out of the pancake cooking process. Its sizeable rectangular shape lets it fit over two stovetop burners to give you a large cooking plate.

The skillfully cast-iron grill and griddle boast excellent heat distribution and retention to give you an even cooking surface. That means you get to cook more pancakes at a go without worrying about under-or overcooking them. It also means you can have your pancake and eggs or some chicken breasts or steak cooking at the same time.

If you like delicious looking pancakes with signature grill marks, you can simply flip the cookware and use the ribbed underside. Both sides offer the same cooking experience with the ribbed side helping to add a bit of zest and flair to your meal. Now you can add grilled cheese sandwiches to your breakfast menu and grilled steak if you’re so inclined. The reversible grill means you don’t have to wait until the weekend to enjoy grilled food items. Now you can have caramelized delicacies anytime you wish without firing up your barbecue grill.

You can trust this cast iron cookware from Lodge to serve you faithfully for a long time. The seasoned cookware is made in the USA and doesn’t have any chemical or synthetic coating. A small layer of oil is all you need to season your griddle and grill unit and keep it in great shape. This grill and griddle combination is built tough for use with various heat sources. It delivers the same consistent results when using it over a campfire, over a stove or in an oven.

PROS

  • check
    Reversible grill and griddle
  • Made of cast iron
  • Seasoned cookware
  • Fits over a double stove

CONS

  • Requires frequent seasoning to keep in shape

2. ​Calphalon Contemporary Nonstick Square Griddle Pan

Do you know why most pans have to be round? No? Neither does this contemporary heavy-duty rectangular pan from Calphalon. This stylish modern pan harnesses every bit of advanced technology to enhance your cooking experience.

Anodized aluminum construction ensures an even distribution of heat while a 3-layer nonstick coat makes for a no-mess cooking surface. Its unique low profile creates the ultimate cooking surface for all your favorite breakfast foods, including pancakes, French toast, crepes, and eggs. If you’re so inclined, you can have some chicken breast going as well. The 11-inch cooking plate means you can get to cook more food in a short time.

The sleek contemporary style of the griddle makes it perfect. It is also lightweight enough to let you hold it with one arm while the other hand turns the pancakes. If you’re a bit fancy, grip the long stay-cool double riveted stainless-steel handle and turn your pancakes by flipping them in the air. The large cooking surface ensures that none of them will land on the floor. Better yet, the nonstick coating makes for low-fat cooking, meaning tossing the pancakes won’t create a mess.

Unlike most other cast iron cookware, this contemporary cookware is dishwasher safe. This griddle makes the perfect cookware for anyone who loves cooking but dreads the cleaning process. You only need to clear any debris and chuck it into the dishwasher with other utensils for a quick and easy clean up. Better yet, the griddle’s hard-anodized aluminum body lets it withstand temperatures of up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. That means it can double up as a baking tray. You can use it to sear your steaks and chicken breast then pop the entire griddle into the oven for a quick bake.

PROS

  • check
    Contemporary square design
  • A triple nonstick coating
  • One-handed handling
  • Oven and dishwasher safe

CONS

  • No sidewalls to prevent oils splashes

3. ​All-Clad 3020 Hard Anodized Aluminum Scratch Resistant Nonstick Griddle

If you’re regularly having guests sleepover or have a large family with voracious appetites, then this anodized double stove griddle is for you. It comes with a 260 square inch cooking plate to let you cook a lot of food at once. You can have up to a dozen burgers or eggs going at the same time without breaking a sweat.

Three layers of nonstick coating on the anodized aluminum core ensure an even distribution of heat on the griddle to eliminate hot spots. All the food items on the griddle will cook evenly, meaning you never have to worry about burning. A small perimeter channel on the skillet drains away the excess oil and juices from the food to let you prepare healthy and delicious meals that are grease-free.

The two stay-cool stainless-steel handles riveted to the sides increase the griddle’s aesthetic appeal while keeping your hands safe. The handles boast a two-inch clearance to safeguard your hands from sizzling oils and to accommodate your cooking mittens.

PROS

  • check
    Extra-large cooking surface
  • Nonstick coating
  • Double handed handling
  • Drains excess oils and juices

CONS

  • Only suits large scale cooking

4. Hawkins Futura Q28 Non-stick Flat Dosa Tava Griddle

If you’re keen on pushing your pancake game to the next level by including some Indian cuisine, then you will certainly appreciate having this griddle in your kitchen. As the name suggests, this nonstick griddle will let you make dosa (gram and rice pancakes), an Indian delicacy, like a seasoned veteran. It even ships out with a cookbook with 11 recipes to guide your culinary adventures.

The griddle boasts an 11-inch cooking surface to allow you to make equally large dosa or pancakes. The one-handed stay-cool handle is attached to a flange to avoid interfering with your cooking surface. The hard anodized 4.88 mm thick cooking surface ensures excellent heat retention and distribution. Since the griddles don’t have hot spots, your pancakes will cook evenly on all sides for a distinctive and appealing look.

The nonstick coating comes in handy when you’re keen to embrace healthy eating. With this stunning griddle, you don’t have to cut out pancakes from your diet plan on account of being greasy. The unique nonstick cooking surface makes for a low-fat cooking adventure to help you reduce your fat intake without limiting your diet options.

PROS

  • check
    Single-handed handling
  • Ultrathick and large cooking plate
  • Nonstick coating
  • Speciality griddle

CONS

  • No raised sides

5. ​Cuisinart MCP45-25NS Double Burner Griddle

If pancakes are part of your family tradition and your clan can't seem to get enough of them, this griddle will let you turn them out by the bucketloads. The 160 square-inch cooking plate means you can have several pancakes going at the same time. The skillet’s superior construction means that you can juggle them all without breaking a sweat.

The super-wide burner sits across two burners to help you prepare a hearty breakfast feast in no time. The pure aluminum ensures even heat distribution over the entire surface to ensure that your food cooks evenly. A triple nonstick coating creates a premium cooking surface that doesn’t burn or char your food. It also complements your efforts to create a delicious, healthy feast for your loved ones.

The griddle is dishwasher safe to make it easy for you to clean up your kitchen before you head out for the day. It’s also compatible with induction cooktops. A pair of rivetted stay-cool handles make for safe handling by keeping your precious hands well above the cooking surface. These handles are high enough to accommodate your cooking mitts.

PROS

  • check
    Extra-large, double burner griddle
  • Excellent heat retention and distributions
  • Triple nonstick coating
  • Dishwasher safe

CONS

  • Unsuitable for small families

FINAL VERDICT

The Calphalon Contemporary Nonstick Square Griddle pan emerges as the clear winner here. The robust construction of this modern griddle lets it double up as baking tray capable of withstanding temperatures of up to 450 Fahrenheit. It has a large cooking plate to let you cook more food items at the same time.

If an aluminum griddle doesn’t do it for you, then you will be happy with the Cuisinart MCP45-25NS Double Burner Griddle. This 10" x 18" griddle is handcrafted in the USA from surgical grade stainless to deliver a superior cooking experience.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Reply: